2025 Mystery Quilt

Welcome to the 2025 Mystery Quilt

Mystery QuiltQuilting with Tamara

I’m thrilled to share this mystery quilt pattern with you. Writing the instructions took longer than I expected, but I’m so excited to finally share it! This quilt is versatile and can be made in a variety of colorways, depending on your personal preference. You can stick to a single color palette, like I did, or get creative with multiple colors. You could choose three colors with a neutral, or select two shades from the same color family, add an accent color, and a neutral. The choice is yours, and it all depends on the level of contrast you want.

Mystery QuiltFabricsQuilting With Tamara

Fabric Colors for Your Mystery Quilt

The sample quilt uses shades from the blue family. I chose light blue, medium-light blue, medium-dark blue, and dark blue. This was the color scheme I was working with when Hubby saw the design and suggested I make it in these tones. As you’ll see, when the quilt is complete, the light fabric creates a striking pattern, and the greater the contrast with the light fabric, the more defined the design will be.

Mystery Quiltgreyscale FabricsQuilting With Tamara

Using Greyscale

If you are unsure that your fabrics will work, take a picture and edit it to show the greyscale version. This is my favorite part of participating in a mystery quilt, but it can be stressful for others. If you don’t want to do a single colorway in your quilt, choose a medium and a dark of one-color family. Then, choose an accent color with a medium-dark value that works well with that color family. Finally, add a light fabric.

Additional Color Family Options

Mystery Quilt Fabric variations
Mystery Quilt Fabric variations

Here are two more color scheme ideas: Start with your medium and dark fabrics, then choose an accent color and a light fabric to complete the look. There’s no “wrong” way to choose your colors—value is the most important factor to keep in mind.

To be honest, I initially considered using greens with a burnt orange accent, but when Hubby commented on the design, I decided to make the quilt in the colors he liked. Sometimes, having someone special in mind helps me stay motivated to finish a quilt, especially when replacing well-loved quilts that are starting to show their age.

Can We Go Scrappy?

If you’re feeling adventurous, going scrappy is absolutely possible! The key is to keep your color families separate and follow the suggested values. If you decide to go this route, I’d love to see your finished quilt top!

Fabric Requirements – based on 40″ wide fabrics

  • Light: 1 3/4 yards
  • Medium – Light: 2 3/4 yards
  • Medium – Dark: 2 yards
  • Dark: 2 1/2 yards

You will receive the cutting directions for each step. Save your leftovers, as you may be able to use them later. The quilt is 72″ square and can easily be enlarged with borders. You will lose the design if you try to make fewer blocks. That’s not to say you can’t make fewer blocks and develop your own layout design in the end.

Tips and Hints for the Mystery Quilt 2025

With each step, I’ll share some tips and tricks to help make the process easier. However, feel free to use the methods that work best for you. There are so many techniques out there, and my goal is to offer suggestions that will help beginning quilters succeed and enjoy the process.

Happy quilting!


If you want to stay informed, use your email below to sign up for notifications. You can also join the Facebook page Quilting with Tamara. You can bookmark this page for quick and easy navigation as the new clue is released.


The patterns for each clue will be found below. You can also watch for new posts with tips and hints.

Mystery Quilt 2025 Clues

  • First Clue
  • Second Clue
  • Third Clue ….. (I haven’t decided yet how many clues to divide the pattern into)


Until next time.

Quilting With Tamara

Leave a Reply